View Other Items in this Archive | View All Archives | Printable Version

August 12, 2008

 

A Regular Meeting of the Township Council of the Township of Roxbury was held on August 12, 2008 at 1715 Route 46, Ledgewood, New Jersey at 7:30 PM.

 

OPEN PUBLIC MEETING STATEMENT

Adequate notice of this meeting of the Township Council of the Township of Roxbury was given as required by the Open Public Meetings act as follows:  Notice was faxed to the Daily Record, the Newark Star Ledger and the Roxbury Register on January 8, 2008; notice was posted on the bulletin board in the main hallway of the Municipal Building on January 8, 2008.

 

ROLL CALL (Present):  Mayor Timothy Smith, Deputy Mayor Kathy DeFillippo, Councilmen Gary Behrens, Fred Hall, Jim Rilee

 

Also Present:  Christopher Raths, Township Manager; Anthony Bucco, Township Attorney; BettyLou DeCroce, Township Clerk; and Amy Rhead, Administrative Aide

 

Absent:  Councilman Martin Schmidt and Councilman Richard Zoschak

 

 

APPROVAL OF MINUTES

July 8th - Regular Meeting

July 22nd - Executive Session - TABLED

 

Mr. Rilee made a motion to approve the Regular Meeting minutes for July 8, 2008.   Deputy Mayor DeFillippo seconded the motion.

 

Roll Call:          Mr. Rilee – Yes                        Deputy Mayor DeFillippo – Yes

                                Mr. Behrens – Yes                   Mr. Hall – Abstain

Mayor Smith - Yes

 

Motion carried 4 to 0 with 1 abstention on July 8, 2008.

 

 

PUBLIC PORTION

Dennis Wine

4 Holly Drive, Succasunna

Mr. Wine asked about state aid as it relates to a bill.  Mr. Raths stated that the aid comes from the County.

 

Robert Kluska

274 Emmans Road, Succasunna

Mr. Kluska asked for clarification on Resolution No. 08-322 “A resolution

authorizing the insertion of an item of revenue in the 2008 budget for additional

funding for recreation opportunities for individuals with disabilities”.  Mr. Hall

stated that it was a grant opportunity that was received for the parents of

exceptional children.  Mr. Raths explained that the budget must be amended to

reflect the insertion of the grant money.  Mr. Raths stated that the State grant

money would be used for a non-profit teen group for exceptional children that

meets in Roxbury.

 

Mayor Smith closed the public portion.

 

 

Mayor Smith amended the agenda to discuss items A and B under “Matters Requested/Referred by Council Members, Manager, Attorney or Clerk”

 

 

 

 

A.  50 Years of Service Certificate of Appreciation

Mayor Smith presented a certificate of appreciation to Charles Alpaugh for 50 years of service as a Roxbury Township volunteer firefighter.  Mr. Alpaugh thanked his friends and family for their continual support throughout the years.

 

B.  “Olde Suckasunny Day” Proclamation

Mayor Smith read a proclamation declaring September 6, 2008, “Olde Suckasunny Day” in the Township of Roxbury.  Ms. Mary Romance, Director, Roxbury Public Library, thanked the Township and the Council for their help in making “Olde Suckasunny Day” a success each year.

 

REPORTS OF COUNCIL LIAISON REPRESENTATIVES, COUNCIL COMMITTEES AND NEW BUSINESS/OLD BUSINESS

A.  New Business

None

B.  Old Business

Procurement Policy

 

Mr. Hall stated that the Recreation Committee met with Jen Russo and discussed the contents of the recreation handout/bulletin that is being created by Dave Stierli, along with other members of Mr. Raths’ staff.

 

Mr. Behrens stated that Fire Company #3’s 50th Anniversary celebration did not seem to be well attended and asked if it could have been better advertised.  Mayor Smith stated that is up to the Fire Company as to how they choose to advertise.

 

Mr. Behrens stated that he has received numerous comments from various residents expressing appreciation for the timely responses that they receive from Township officials whenever they have a concern.

 

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo stated that she had given Mr. Raths recommendations for the recreation bulletin.  Mr. Raths stated that he had passed those suggestions on to Jen Russo.

 

Mr. Hall stated that there is a tight time frame and any requests need to be submitted within one week in order to be considered for the publication.

 

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo stated that the next Neighborhood meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, August 19, 2008.

 

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo stated that both she and Mr. Behrens have received inquiries from a resident in regard to the status of the Berkshire Valley park/playground project.  Mr. Raths stated that the playground equipment has been ordered, that the Walking Path should go out to bid within a few weeks, and the contract should be awarded by early September.  Deputy Mayor DeFillippo asked if the Berkshire Valley park project includes a gate.  Mr. Raths stated that he would check on this.  Deputy Mayor DeFillippo asked if we could have a bench and/or picnic table at the Berkshire Valley park.  Mr. Raths stated that we could accommodate that request.  Deputy Mayor DeFillippo also stated that she has received complaints from residents about weeds at the location.

 

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo asked why there is not a gate at the Dell Avenue park.

 

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo stated that an Eyland Avenue resident has contacted her in regard to an ongoing drainage problem he has been having.  Mr. Raths stated that there was a pond that is now filled in and that the water that this resident is experiencing on his property is definitely ground water.  Mr. Raths will have Mr. Blood follow up with the resident to see if we can be of assistance.  Deputy Mayor DeFillippo stated that she would like to be kept up to date on any developments relating to this issue.

Mr. Rilee stated that the DPW Committee met last night.  Mr. Raths stated that the bid specifications should be sent out in the fall, with the awarding of a contract in the winter and a projected groundbreaking in the spring.

 

Mr. Rilee stated that he had attended the Fire Chiefs meeting and advised that the Chiefs would like to be updated by the Planning Board as plans get revised  during the development process.

 

Mayor Smith stated that the Open Space Meeting that was scheduled for last week was canceled (some members were unavailable due to vacation).  Mayor Smith stated that the County grant for the Landing recreation project has been resubmitted.

 

Mayor Smith commented that the Water and Sewer Committee has not had a meeting.  Mr. Raths stated that a meeting would be held on the morning of August 15, 2008.

 

Mayor Smith asked Mr. Raths to keep him informed about any developments in regard to the Berkshire Valley park project.  Mr. Raths stated that he would keep the Mayor and Council informed about the progress via his weekly Information Update.

 

Mr. Raths stated that the Mayor and Council have been invited to a 5K race on Netcong Day, Sunday, September 7, 2008.

 

Mr. Raths stated that he would include correspondence in the next Communications packet from Habitat for Humanity asking to build a two-family home on the corner of Edith Road, as opposed to a single-family dwelling.

 

Mayor Smith asked if anyone would be available to attend the Merry Heart Opening on Friday, August 15, 2008.  Mr. Raths stated that he would be attending.

 

Mayor Smith stated that he would not be available to attend the Noah’s Ark fundraiser on September 21, 2008.

 

Mayor Smith stated that the PBA would be conducting a 5K Run/Walk on Tuesday, September 9, 2008 to benefit the Field of Dreams.

 

MATTERS REQUESTED/REFERRED BY COUNCIL MEMBERS, MANAGER, ATTORNEY OR CLERK

A.  50 Years of Service Certificate – previously discussed

B.  “Olde Suckasunny Day Proclamation” – previously discussed

C.  Melissa Lane Block Party

D.  Forest Drive Block Party

E.  SSC one day Liquor License September 21, 2008

 

Mr. Rilee mad a motion to approve items C, D, and E as listed above.  Mr. Hall seconded the motion.

 

Roll Call:                      Mr. Rilee – Yes                        Mr. Hall – Yes

                                    Mr. Behrens – Yes                   Deputy Mayor DeFillippo - Yes

                                    Mayor Smith – Yes

 

Motion carried 5 to 0.

 

 

F.  Proposal for Preparation of Third Round Housing Elements Fair Share      Plan

The Council members discussed their ongoing frustration with COAH’s continuing rule and ratio changes and the importance of awarding a contract to a company that can help Roxbury comply, by the end of the year, in order to avoid possible penalties.

 

 

08-332             RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE AWARD OF A PROFESSIONAL SERVICES CONTRACT TO FRANCIS J. BANISCH, III, P.P./AICP OF BANISCH ASSOCIATES, INC. FOR THE PREPARATION OF THE TOWNSHIP’S HOUSING ELEMENT AND FAIR SHARE PLAN IN SUPPORT OF THE TOWNSHIP’S COAH APPLICATION

 

 

Mr. Rilee mad a motion to approve Resolution 08-332.  Mr. Hall seconded the motion.

 

Roll Call:                      Mr. Rilee – Yes                        Mr. Hall – Yes

                                    Mr. Behrens – Yes                   Deputy Mayor DeFillippo - Yes

                                    Mayor Smith – Yes

 

Motion carried 5 to 0.

 

 

Mr. Rilee brought up for discussion a letter received last month from Assembly Minority leader Alex DeCroce requesting a list of mandates that have been imposed on the Township by the State and the Council feels are unfair. 

Mr. Raths will follow up on a previous communications from Alex DeCroce

 

DRAFT ORDINANCES FOR DISCUSSION

None

 

INTRODUCTION OF PROPOSED ORDINANCES

None

 

HEARING AND ADOPTION OF ORDINANCES ON SECOND READING

None

 

DRAFT RESOLUTION FOR DISCUSSION

None

 

INTRODUCTION AND ADOPTION OF RESOLUTIONS

08-305             A RESOLUTION INCORPORATING BY REFERENCE HEREIN AND APPROVING THE FOLLOWING NUMBERED RESOLUTIONS LISTED ON THE WORKSHOP COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA FOR THIS DATE: 08-306, 08-307, 08-308, 08-309, 08-310, 08-311, 08-312, 08-313, 08-314, 08-315, 08-316, 08-317, 08-318, 08-319, 08-320, 08-321, 08-322, 08-323, 08-324, 08-325, 08-326, 08-327, 08-328, 08-329, 08-330, 08-333

 

Mr. Rilee mad a motion to approve Resolution 08-305.  Deputy Mayor DeFillippo seconded the motion.

 

Roll Call:                      Mr. Rilee – Yes

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo - Yes

                                    Mr. Behrens – Yes

Mr. Hall – Yes, with a recusal on check no. 08-57807, item #40

                                    Mayor Smith – Yes

 

Motion carried 5 to 0, with one recusal on check no. 08-57807, item #40

 

 

08-306             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING A SANITARY SEWER ALLOCATION TO PATRICK J. LYNCH, JR. FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 505 MAIN STREET, LANDING; BLOCK 10301, LOT 2.03

 

08-307             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE REFUND OF UNUSED ENGINEERING INSPECTION FEES TO MARK TUCCI, FOR A PROJECT KNOWN AS TUCCI MINOR SUBDIVISION LOCATED AT 10 SOUTH SECOND STREET, KENVIL; BLOCK 2611, LOT 12.02

 

08-308             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. RO-01-07-0024, 10 SOUTH SECOND STREET, KENVIL; BLOCK 2611, LOT 12.02

 

08-309             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. RO-07-08-080, 17 CONDIT STREET, SUCCASUNNA; BLOCK 3403, LOT 2

 

08-310             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. SEP2606, 290 EMMANS ROAD, FLANDERS; BLOCK 4101, LOT 9

 

08-311             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. RO-01-07-0035, 5 KURT DRIVE, FLANDERS; BLOCK 7601, LOT 7

 

08-312             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. OCT3006, 8 TAMARACK DRIVE, SUCCASUNNA; BLOCK 4401, LOT 32

 

08-313             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. RO-06-08-057, 33 FOX CHASE LANE, LEDGEWOOD; BLOCK 9205, LOT 46

 

08-314             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. RO-07-08-064, 27 BENT STREET, KENVIL; BLOCK 3903, LOT 8

 

08-315             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. RO-05-08-037, 526 VAIL ROAD, LANDING; BLOCK 11405, LOT 3

 

08-316             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. DEC1106, 38 UNNEBERG AVENUE, SUCCASUNNA; BLOCK 3101, LOT 29

 

08-317             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE REFUND OF ENGINEERING INSPECTION ESCROW TO BRIAN O’NEILL IN CONNECTION WITH MINOR SOIL PERMIT NO. MIN SOIL-06-08-019, 51 FOX CHASE LANE; BLOCK 9205, LOT 13

 

08-318             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE POSTED FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. AUG2107, 11 HORIZON DRIVE, SUCCASUNNA; BLOCK 5202, LOT 30

 

08-319             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE REFUND OF UNUSED ESCROW MONIES PREVIOUSLY DEPOSITED WITH THE TOWNSHIP OF ROXBURY FOR DEVELOPMENT MATTERS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER XIII (LAND USE) OF THE REVISED GENERAL ORDINANCES OF THE TOWNSHIP OF ROXBURY

 

08-320             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE REFUND OF UNUSED ESCROW MONIES PREVIOUSLY DEPOSITED WITH THE TOWNSHIP OF ROXBURY FOR DEVELOPMENT MATTERS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER XIII (LAND USE) OF THE REVISED GENERAL ORDINANCES OF THE TOWNSHIP OF ROXBURY

 

08-321             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ACCEPTANCE OF A MAINTENANCE BOND AND SUBSEQUENT RELEASE OF A CASH PERFORMANCE BOND AND SURETY BOND FOR A TREE REPLACEMENT PERMIT FOR FRESENIUS MEDICAL CENTER/KENVIL MEDICAL LOCATED ON ROUTE 46; BLOCK 4002, LOT 16

 

08-322             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INSERTION OF AN ITEM OF REVENUE IN THE 2008 BUDGET FOR ADDITIONAL FUNDING FOR RECREATION OPPORTUNITIES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DISABILITIES

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo asked if this is additional money for recreation opportunities for individuals with disabilities, or if this is the amount they receive every year.  Mr. Raths stated that this Resolution is the result of a new procedure that will insert grant money into the budget as it is received and that this is the same amount they receive every year, not additional money.

 

08-323             RESOLUTION FOR RENEWAL OF MEMBERSHIP IN THE MORRIS COUNTY MUNICIPAL JOINT INSURANCE FUND

BettyLou DeCroce stated that we would be receiving a check from HIF for

approximately $122,000, in September.  Ms. DeCroce further stated she would

know more about dividends in regards to the JIF after her meeting with the finance

committee on Friday in Saddlebrook.

 

08-324             A RESOLUTION AMENDING THE MEMBERSHIP OF

THE TOWNSHIP FIRE DEPARTMENT

 

08-325             RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING REFUND OF TAXES FOR A

TOTALLY DISABLED VETERAN EXEMPTION

           

08-326             RESOLUTION OF THE TOWNSHIP COUNCIL OF THE TOWNSHIP OF ROXBURY EXTENDING THE GRACE PERIOD FOR PAYMENT OF THE AUGUST 2008 QUARTERLY TAX BILLS

 

08-327             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ACCEPTANCE OF AN

IRREVOCABLE LETTER OF CREDIT FOR RIGHT-OF-WAY EXCAVATION PERMIT NO. RO-07-08-068 FOR WELLFLEET DEVELOPER’S INC. FOR THE OFFSITE WATER MAIN CONSTRUCTION REGARDING THE VILLAGES AT ROXBURY DEVELOPMENT

 

08-328             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE AWARD OF A CONTRACT FOR THE PURCHASE OF PLAN STORAGE RACKS FROM PATHFINDER VUE-FILE SYSTEMS FOR THE CONSTRUCTION DEPARTMENT

 

08-329             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE REFUND OF TAXES

 

08-330                          A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE PAYMENT OF BILLS

Mr. Rilee asked about a check written to the Circle Motel for public assistance and if we, the Township, could get COAH credit for such payments.

 

08-333             A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE AWARD OF AN EMERGENCY CONTRACT TO KINGSTON TURF FARMS PURSUANT TO N.J.S.A. 40A: 11-6 FOR THE INSTALLATION OF APPROXIMATELY 80,000 SQUARE FEET OF SOD AT HORSESHOE LAKE FIELD #1

Mr. Hall thanked Dave Stierli and his staff for efforts in getting this sod project completed in such a timely and effective manner.  Mr. Behrens asked if replacement sod for Field #1 had been part of the budget.  Mr. Raths stated that we had originally planned on doing emergency repairs to selected areas that were in need, not a full replacement of sod.  Mr. Hall stated that the $30,000 was coming from the increase in recreational fees that was approved by the Council and this is not a tax increase.  Mr. Hall further stated that the irrigation system was donated by football and lacrosse.  Mr. Raths stated that $10,000 was being used from the Open Space fund, but it would be returned from the Recreation trust fund by the end of the year.  Mr. Rilee asked if Roxbury Water supplies the water for the irrigation system.  Mr. Raths stated that Roxbury Water does provide the water to Horseshoe Lake and there is a meter.  Mr. Rilee stated that we should look at the possibility of using the well water instead of paying Roxbury Water for water usage at this location.  Mr. Raths stated that he would look into this and would get back to Council members.

 

PERSONNEL CHANGES

Memo from Judy Riley dated August 6, 2008

 

COMMUNICATIONS

July 25, 2008

 

#7  Correspondence from Nick DePalma to Mayor Smith, dated July 21, 2008,

re:  Resignation from both the Lake Hopatcong Commission and the Lake

Musconetcong Regional Planning Board

The Clerk’s office will send a letter of appreciation to Mr. DePalma.

 

Mr. Rilee made a motion to appoint John Ciaramella as a member of the Lake Musconetcong Regional Planning Board.  Mr. Behrens seconded the motion.

 

Roll Call:          All in Favor – Yes

 

Motion carried 5 to 0.

 

 

#8  Correspondence from Chris Raths, Township Manager, to Walter Krich, Director, Morris County Department of Planning Development & Technology, dated July 21, 2008, re:  Outline of summary and concerns as discussed at the Council meeting of July 8, 2008

Mr. Rilee asked Mr. Raths to copy the Freeholders on any communications from the Township to the County.  Mr. Raths stated that he would make sure that the Freeholders would be copied on communications to the County.

 

#9  Mayors Fax Advisory, dated July 22, 2008, re:  “Public Safety Related Costs; Property Tax Relief (S-1976/A-2982)”

Mayor Smith and other Council members do not agree with this.

 

August 1, 2008

#1, item H: Shared Services

Mr. Hall asked for an update about utilizing fuel with a lower octane level.  Mr. Raths stated that he asked Mr. Blood about that today and would get back to the Council with the answer.

 

#1, item K: Commerce Blvd/RT 10/Main St.

Mr. Rilee asked if the attached letter had been sent to Commissioner Kolluri.  Mayor Smith reported that he had received a call from Deputy Freeholder Director Gene Feyl stating that he and Susan Zellman had spoken to the people in Trenton about the TIP and that they had agreed, again, to put the money back in the budget for this project.  Mayor Smith requested that we get something in writing to that effect.

 

#1, item Q: Berkshire Valley Road Bridge Flasher

Mr. Behrens asked about this item.  Mr. Raths stated that he had just received an email confirmation today for the approval of this item and it should be awarded by the end of August.

 

#1, item R: Sanitary Sewer Extensions:  Read Court, Deer Lane, Harrison Avenue, Carey and Cornhollow Roads

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo asked Mr. Raths if this meeting had taken place.  Mr.

Raths stated that the meeting had taken place and the Highlands staff saw no

reason that we shouldn’t proceed.  The next step is for Roxbury Township to put a

preliminary plan together that will be presented to the residents in the Fall.

 

August 8, 2008

#4 Correspondence from Gerald Rohsler, Morris County Division of Transportation, to Gordon Fuller, dated July 30, 2008, re: Transloading of plastic pellets

Mr. Rilee asked Mr. Bucco about this.  Mr. Bucco stated that he handling this matter.

 

#7 Correspondence from BettyLou DeCroce, to Tony Bucco, dated August 4, 2008, re: Title 39

Mr. Rilee thanked Ms. DeCroce for keeping on top of this matter.

 

#13 Interoffice Memorandum from BettyLou DeCroce to Tony Bucco, dated August 7, 2008, re: Welcome Signs

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo asked about this item.  Ms. DeCroce stated that Mr. Valiante would like to have assurance that he is not responsible for maintenance or other issues that may arise with the “Welcome to Roxbury” sign.  Mr. Raths and Mr. Bucco stated that we have an agreement that would address this concern.  Ms. DeCroce stated that she has been unable to locate any such agreement.  Mr. Raths stated that he would check to see if he has it and would forward it to Ms. DeCroce so that she could send a copy to Mr. Valiante.

 

#14 Correspondence from Richard Sweeney, to Mayor/Council, dated July 23, 2008, re: Manor Parkway and Kings Parkway

Mr. Hall asked whether this should go before the Planning Board first.  Mr. Raths stated that he has turned this issue over to the Engineering and Planning Departments and will update the Council at a later date.

 

Mayor Smith asked Mr. Bucco to send the staff evaluation forms to the Council members so that a review of BettyLou DeCroce, Municipal Clerk, could be completed.

 

The second Public Portion was inadvertently omitted from this agenda.  The Council discussed the number of Public Portions on the Regular Meeting agendas vs. Workshop Meeting agendas.

 

EXECUTIVE SESSION

08-331             A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWNSHIP COUNCIL OF THE TOWNSHIP OF ROXBURY, IN THE COUNTY OF MORRIS, NEW JERSEY AUTHORIZING CONFERENCE OF THE TOWNSHIP COUNCIL WITH THE PUBLIC EXCLUDED

 

Deputy Mayor DeFillippo made a motion to adopt Resolution 08-331 for Executive Session.  Mr. Behrens seconded the motion.

 

Roll Call:          All in Favor - Yes

 

Motion carried 5 to 0.

 

At 9:40 PM Council returned to the Regular Meeting.

 

ADJOURNMENT

At 9:40 PM Mr. Rilee made a motion to adjourn the Regular Meeting.  Mr. Hall seconded the motion.

 

All In Favor – Yes

 

Motion carried 5 to 0.

 

 

Submitted By:

 

 

 

________________________________

BettyLou DeCroce

Township Clerk

 

MINUTES APPROVED BY COUNCIL

DATE:                        September 23, 2008

ROLL CALL:            Mr. Rilee – yes Mr. Behrens – yes

                                    Mrs. DeFillippo – yes   Mr. Zoschak – abstain

                                    Mayor Smith - yes